10.31.2012 The Fillmore Silver Spring, Silver Spring, MD, USA

Set 1: Gurgle > Puppet String, Plunger, Deeper > Preamble > Mantis, Domino Theory, Glory -> The Floor[1]

Set 2: Help On the Way > Slipknot! > Jessica, Girlfriend is Better -> Fool in the Rain > Halloween theme > Fool in the Rain, Forty-Six & 2, Roundabout, Money For Nothing[2], Another Brick in the Wall/Thriller

Encore: Ophelia > Miss Tinkle's Overture

[1] with Halloween theme (John Carpenter) teases
[2] debut, Dire Straits

Notes:
band played with masks ("The Mostly Dead Ex Presidents, A Vice President, and a First Lady"): Brendan was Bill Clinton, Jake was Ronald Reagan, Joel was Dick Cheney, Kris was Richard Nixon, Andy was Barack Obama, and Ryan was Hillary Clinton
second set was an All Night Wrong cover set, comprised entirely of fan voted cover songs
Jessica was teased before Girlfriend Is Better
last Jessica 04.18.2008 (523 shows)
last Halloween theme 10.31.2007 (573 shows)
last Ophelia 12.01.2006 (680 shows)

Support: The Bright Light Social Hour
Purchase via UMLive: 10.31.2012, The Fillmore, Silver Spring, MD